Why Before How: Understanding the Reason Behind Your Dog’s Behaviour

The questions I’m asked most

Most of the questions I’m asked start with “how”. How do I stop my dog pulling? How do I get him to come back? How do I stop her jumping up at visitors?

They’re good questions, and they usually come from someone who has already tried a few things, is a bit tired, and would just like life with their dog to feel easier. My answer nearly always starts with a question of my own: why do you think your dog is doing it?

That isn’t me avoiding the question. In my experience, the why is where the how comes from. I’ve believed this for most of my years living with and training dogs, and every course I’ve been on since has only strengthened it.

Behaviour is a dog’s way of meeting a need

Dogs don’t do things to annoy us, test us or get one over on us. Every behaviour, the ones we love and the ones we’d rather not see, is doing a job for the dog. Broadly, that job is usually one of these:

  • Getting something they want — food, attention, play, the thrill of a chase, a really good sniff
  • Getting away from something — a dog that worries them, a hand reaching over their head, a sudden noise
  • Coping — settling themselves when they’re stressed, bored or over-excited (chewing, licking, zoomies)
  • Their body — pain, discomfort, hunger, tiredness or hormonal changes

Dogs are outcome-led. When a behaviour gets them what they need, they’re likely to do it again. That’s not a flaw in your dog; it’s how all animals learn, including us.

Why stopping a behaviour on its own rarely lasts

If we focus only on stopping a behaviour, the need behind it is still there. Your dog will usually find another way to meet it, and sometimes that new way is one we like even less.

Take a dog who barks at other dogs because they feel worried. If the barking is simply suppressed, the worry hasn’t gone anywhere. The dog may go quiet but still feel frightened, or skip the barking and move straight to lunging or snapping, because the early warning no longer felt safe to give.

Now imagine instead that we help that dog feel safer: more distance from other dogs, the chance to look away, rewarding calm moments. The barking has much less of a job to do, so it fades, and what replaces it is built on the dog feeling better, not just behaving differently. That’s the kind of change that lasts.

The “why” that matters most is the one happening now

When a dog has come to us from a rescue, or we don’t know much about their early life, it’s natural to wonder what happened to them. That history can give us useful context, and it’s worth being gentle with a dog who may have had a hard start.

But what keeps a behaviour going today is usually right in front of us. Two simple things to notice:

  • What happens just before? Where are you, who’s around, what time of day is it, how has your dog’s day been so far?
  • What happens just after? What does your dog get, or get away from, as a result?

Those two observations will often tell you more than any amount of guessing about the past, and they’re the parts you can actually change.

Check the body first

This is the one I’d encourage every owner to keep at the front of their mind. Research into pain and behaviour in dogs suggests that discomfort sits behind far more unwanted behaviour than most of us would expect. A dog who is sore, tired or unwell can’t respond the way they usually do, and it can easily look like stubbornness.

Things worth noticing:

  • A behaviour that has appeared or changed suddenly
  • Behaviour that’s worse at certain times — after long walks, on cold days, first thing in the morning
  • Sensitivity to being touched, groomed or picked up in certain places
  • Reluctance to jump into the car, use the stairs or settle in their usual spot

If any of these ring a bell, your vet is the best first step, and depending on what they find, a Dynamic Dog Practitioner may be part of the picture too. Training can’t fix something that hurts, and no owner should feel silly for checking.

Be wary of the labels

Stubborn. Spiteful. Dominant. “He knows he’s done wrong.” These are also answers to the question why, and most of us have used one or two of them at some point, often because someone told us that’s what was going on.

The trouble is that these labels point us towards correcting the dog rather than understanding them. That “guilty” look, for example, is usually a dog responding to our tone and body language and trying to defuse the situation, not a sign they understand what they did an hour ago. Swapping the label for a more accurate one is often the first real step forward.

Five questions to start with

When a behaviour isn’t what you’d like, these five questions are a good place to begin. They form the heart of the Canine Connection Framework:

  1. Physical — Is my dog comfortable, rested and well enough to do this?
  2. Understanding — Does my dog really know what I’m asking, here, in this place?
  3. Relationship — Does my dog trust me, and want to be with me?
  4. Motivation — Is what I’m offering worth more than what else is going on?
  5. Clarity — Are the rules the same from everyone, every time?

Often one of them stands out straight away. To see which one to look at first for your dog, try the Five Questions Check. It takes about three minutes.

In the meantime, management isn’t cheating

Understanding the why takes a little time, and life with your dog carries on while you work it out. It’s completely fair to put some simple management in place in the meantime: a lead or long line, more distance, a baby gate, walking at quieter times.

Management isn’t a failure or a shortcut. It stops your dog practising the behaviour while you work on the reason behind it, and it takes some of the pressure off both of you.

Understanding helps you, too

There’s one more reason I put the why first, and it’s for the owner as much as the dog. When you understand why your dog is doing something, it stops feeling personal. Your dog isn’t defying you or trying to embarrass you. They’re doing what makes sense to them with what they know and how they feel.

That shift makes it much easier to stay calm, patient and kind, with your dog and with yourself. And it’s the heart of being your dog’s advocate: asking why, listening to the answer, and helping them meet their needs in ways that work for both of you.

Scroll to Top